Talk:Character Idea/Avatar Aang/Purple-Dragoon/@comment-26272757-20170710055534/@comment-33046846-20170711004655

I'm with France on this one. The categories, in my opinion, are a terrible idea. First, users may take the bad idea category personally, as they maybe put a lot of time and effort into it, but when someone adds the category, they may get offended. Second, these are opinion based. Categories should be factual, as while people have different opinions, facts are the same. Third, users have abused this category by adding the very good ideas category to their ideas, and it's really biased and unfair to other ideas. Fourth, some of the reasons ideas have gotten the categories have been completely ridiculous. There are some ideas that got the category just because of the ideas basis. For example, Character Idea/SpongeBob only got the bad ideas category because it was based on SpongeBob. It wasn't even because of the content in the article, how the power shots are, etc - it was only because of the fact that it was based on SpongeBob. Fifth, this should not be displayed in a category. Instead, it should be an opinion in a comment. A user can say if they like it or not, which is what happens a lot. Categories, again, are supposed to be factual, not opinionated. Sixth, ideas are only...well, ideas. They are fan fiction for Head Soccer. They are not supposed to be taken 100% seriously. These are just ideas, not what's actually in the game, which leads me to ask - why is fan fiction and the real game stuff on the same wiki? There should be a Head Soccer Fanon Wiki, and the ideas can be transferred there. Anyway, that's kind of off-topic, so I'll bring up my last reason. Seventh, there's no advice in the category. All the category gives is "Good ideas" or "Bad ideas" or stuff like that. The user who adds the category does not actually give reasons why in a comment most of the time. It's hard to receive feedback and know how to improve the idea when you simply just get "okay ideas" or another tag. It's just the category - no advice, no feedback, nothing but the label.

For these reasons, in my opinion, the categories should be removed.